Mention urban legends to a group of high school students, and chances are at least a few of them will have a story to contribute or a connection to make to something they swear happened to someone their cousin is best friends with. Maybe they’ve heard the one about the killer hiding in the backseat, or under the parked car in a deserted mall parking lot late at night. Maybe it’s the classic about an escaped murderer with a hook for a hand, or the timeless and ever-popular ghostly vanishing hitchhiker.

Even students who don’t recognize any of these older classic urban legends probably know a newer version of one of the same tales–creepy stories and rumors passed around online and presented as something that really happened. That’s part of what makes urban legends so much fun to use in the classroom. Students are usually interested in them before you even begin the lesson.
But urban legends are useful for far more than grabbing students’ attention. They offer an accessible way to introduce students to folklore and, more importantly, to get them thinking about the relationship between stories and the cultures that tell them.
Urban Legends as Folklore that Reflects Cultural Norms and Expectations
Students sometimes hear the word folklore and immediately think of fairy tales, ancient myths, or stories people told hundreds of years ago, but urban legends are a good reminder that folklore is still very much alive. Folklore includes the stories, traditions, beliefs, customs, sayings, and other ideas that are passed from person to person within a culture, and urban legends fit perfectly into that definition. They’re stories that circulate informally, with no identifiable original author, and they evolve over time and as people retell them.
One of the most interesting things about urban legends is that they’re typically told as if they’ve actually happened. They don’t take place hundreds of years ago in a spooky castle or a faraway kingdom, but they’re always something that happened to someone’s cousin’s fiancee’s brother. Or a friend of a friend’s next door neighbor. Or a student at another school two towns over. The details are just believable enough to make you wonder, and that sense of possibility is one of the things that separates urban legends from other kinds of traditional stories. It’s also what makes them so memorable.
Method 1: Start With Some Classic Urban Legends
There are tons of these stories out there, not all of them scary, though many of them are. Or at the very least, they’re amped up on the creep-out factor (Spiders in the Hairdo, for example), or rife with grisly subject matter (The Body in the Bed). There are also some funny ones, more than a few of which involve embarrassing bodily functions.

However, in my experience, high school students really like the scary stories, especially the ones with teenagers as the protagonist(s). A few classics include The Hookman, The Babysitter and the Man Upstairs, The Hairy-Armed Hitchhiker, Alligators in the Sewers, The Kidney Heist, and The Killer in the Backseat.
You need not buy any books about urban legends to teach them to your students, either, though I certainly recommend reading one or two of them. Jan Harold Brunvand is widely considered to be the person responsible for popularizing urban legends, and he’s got some fantastic books that have versions not only of the legends, but also some discussion of their origins and how they can be interpreted culturally.
However, urban legends are also widely available online, and I have a unit featuring four classic tales with analysis and response questions designed to get students thinking. For my unit, the text of four classic urban legends are included, as well as a brief article I wrote summarizing what they are and how they function as cautionary tales within our culture and society.
Method 2: Get Students Talking by Asking Good Questions
One of my favorite approaches is to ask students to try and figure out the unwritten rule, or rules, the tale embodies, because most urban legends are cautionary in nature, and function as a warning to a particular audience. Some of the things they seek to teach listeners are basic guidelines like, Don’t go somewhere isolated, even if you’re not alone; Be wary of strangers; Pay attention to your surroundings; Listen when you’re warned about danger; and Be careful when you’re alone, even if you’re somewhere you deem “safe.”
Once students begin to identify some of these basic warnings, you can push the discussion further with more probing questions like, What behavior does this story seem to approve/disapprove of? Who is expected to follow this rule or conform to this norm/expectation? This is the area where urban legends can really shine and become especially useful for teaching students about how folklore can act as a mirror for culture.
Take The Hookman, for example. It’s not just a story about an escaped killer. At the center of it is a teenage couple who’ve gone somewhere private together, and this legend became widespread during a time when American teenagers had increasing access to cars and greater independence from their parents. Suddenly, teenagers could go places without adults knowing exactly where they were or what they were doing.

Looking at The Hookman in that context give students much more to discuss. Is it simply a scary story about an escaped criminal with a weapon for a prosthesis? Or could it also be interpreted as a warning about teenage independence, dating, sexuality, and violating expectations? There doesn’t need to be one correct answer, and in fact, the discussion is usually better when students see different possibilities.
The larger idea I always want students to take away from urban legends is that folklore reflects the culture that produces it. Stories don’t just come from nowhere. The things people tell stories about often reveal their fears, values, expectations, and concerns, and as society changes, folklore changes with it.
Consider some of the popular urban legend tropes: cars gave people freedom and independence, but they also created new dangers, and there are plenty of urban legends involving lonely roads, hitchhikers, back seats, gas stations, and broken-down vehicles in isolated locations with dangerous individuals allegedly roaming around.
The telephone brought people into our homes without requiring them to physically enter, so naturally as this technology became widespread, it featured in frightening stories about anonymous callers, threatening voices, and privacy being violated in spaces we had always considered sacred and safe.

The setting of urban legends is also worth noting: Why does a parking garage (or other isolated location) feel creepy at night? Why are so many urban legends about ordinary places suddenly becoming unsafe? These settings can reveal what a culture considers familiar, private, safe, or threatening.
Beyond setting, urban legends often present an idea about who among us should be considered “dangerous,” and they don’t always reflect cultural expectations as something we want to reinforce. For example, sometimes these stories reveal stereotypes, prejudices, or assumptions that were common when the stories circulated, but these are often ideas that we don’t want to teach as “true” to our children (i.e., that people with mental health challenges are all dangerous and present a threat, which is a common theme in many urban legends like The Hookman).
Ask students to pay attention to the roles people have in these stories. Who is vulnerable? Who is dangerous? Who needs protection, and who provides it? How are women and men portrayed differently? How are teenagers portrayed? What do the stories seem to be saying about strangers?
These types of open-ended, probing questions can lead to some really thoughtful discussions about the difference between identifying a cultural norm and agreeing with it. Students can recognize that an urban legend reflects an attitude toward a particular group of people (i.e., a person with a disability or someone with a mental health diagnosis), or reinforces a traditional gender norm, without accepting those attitudes and norms themselves. In fact, questioning those assumptions is an important part not just of analyzing folklore, but also of teaching students to reject traditional stereotypes and prejudices.

Method 3: Make a Modern Connection
This lesson works well if you allow students to discuss their own experiences with urban legends, although you should be prepared for a vociferous discussion where everyone will want to talk. Many of them will bring up various forms of social media where stories circulate, as well as forums like Reddit, various podcasts, or other online spaces. Their world is increasingly playing out on a screen via the internet, which is where many of their experiences will be, though hopefully some of them will still tell you they heard an urban legend at a sleepover or around a campfire with friends or family.
This can also help create a connection between folklore and media literacy, and this typically sparks a discussion with the following types of questions:
- Why do scary stories seem to spread so quickly?
- Why are people so tempted to share shocking or sensationalized information, even when we’re not positive it’s true?
- Why does hearing that something happened to a “friend of a friend” make it seem more believable?
You can also use this discussion to help students distinguish between an urban legend, a rumor, misinformation, and disinformation. Students don’t need to leave the lesson thinking that every false story is an urban legend, but instead, you want them to critically examine the information they’re exposed to, no matter the subject matter. Especially when they’re consuming online information, this is a valuable skill, because so often our kids don’t seem to know how to figure out if something is reliable or not.
Why Urban Legends are Worth Taking the Time to Examine
First and foremost, urban legends are engaging, immersive stories that will keep your high schoolers on task and interested, and that’s an important consideration. However, more importantly, these stories are useful because they give students a manageable way to practice a fairly sophisticated kind of analysis. Instead of stopping at plot or theme, students begin asking what a story reveals about the people who tell it:

- What did they fear?
- What did they value?
- What behavior did they expect from one another?
- Who or what did they distrust?
Once students understand that folklore reflects the society and culture that create it, an urban legend stops being just a creepy story about a hook hanging from a car door. Instead, it’s a piece of cultural evidence, a fingerprint offering us a glimpse into the thoughts, feelings, and outlook of the folks who tell these stories.
Urban Legends: Close Readings of Cautionary Tales

